hypfer

Answering the Headline: Not really, no.

Things are the way they are not because they would be difficult but because various systemic incentives and goals fought out each other, leading to the outcomes we then saw.

This balance these various forces fought out relied on a bunch of undocumented assumptions about reality. Every time one of those breaks, you get disruptions. LLMs broke quite a few of them, leading to a lot of CVEs lately.

dgoodell

I think it was a business decision to make it too complex for humans. I don’t think fundamentals were prioritized as much as features, resulting in a fragile house of cards.

There’s a reason it doesn’t look like most engineering. If it was a bridge it would have collapsed long ago and killed people.

amelius

The always changing requirements are what make it too complex for humans.

ssrc

Maybe for some software systems it was. For most systems, the problem was just professional immaturity caused by the eternal September state the profession is in since the beginning.

yepyoukno

Many handle it just fine.

ex-aws-dude

I mean if you zoom out the whole lesson we keep learning over and over with AI/ML is “we are not smart enough to design this function”

AIShill101

Yea I agree with the article wholly. This new era of AI assisted or driven coding is going to help us extend our capability way beyond anything humans could've built.

show comments