PaulHoule

I would like to see this claim justified:

   In the Dewey Decimal System, a book on gardening could potentially be in 
   any of the four places in the system that contained gardening content. 
   With Wayfinder, it’s all in the same place.
I think there is always a question of where to file something, like a book about the history of gardening in England could be filed under gardening or the history of England. You could do better than old systems but you're not getting it right always.

I think the greatest embarrassment in Dewey and Library of Congress (LC) is how they handled computers. Dewey has a trash section at the beginning and computers wind up right after UFOs and bigfoot but oddly most occult subjects end up in the 130's except for a tiny bit in the 398.4 but my witchy friends would be happy to know The Spiral Dance is filed at 299.

LC on the other hand puts almost everything about computers in QA76 except for some clusters in the TK area and some oddly general things in QA75. (In LC The Spiral Dance is filed along with more lurid books on witchcraft that Dewey files at 133.4) Instead of "generic" and "math" and in some alternate universe it would have been reasonable to put computers under electronics in 621.3 and in fact you might find a few books there about how gates are constructed in CMOS there if you're lucky.

The trouble is that computers expanded to embrace everything so books like "How to process your photographs in Adobe Lightroom" ends up in the 0's that really ought to be filed in the 600's (photography as technology) or the 770s (photography as art.) Stuff like that ends up in 0's in Dewey but in LC usually gets filed in the TRs, though if it was like Dewey they'd file photography under the NDs.

The advantage a "bookstore-like" system has is that if it isn't set in stone you can change it.

show comments
ilamont

There used to be an old bookstore just outside of Boston called the New England Mobile Book Fair. It had long ago ceased to be mobile, and was installed in some type of former industrial building consisting of a warehouse like room, winding passages, and former offices, 30k square feet in all (2,787 m2).

It was organized by broad genre (childrens, fiction, etc.), publisher, then author. Niche genres were scattered around in nooks or on certain walls. I don't remember if imprints were handled as individual publishers or mixed in with the parent, or it was ad hoc (very likely!)

It was fun to browse, but unless you knew the publisher the only way to find certain titles or even types of books was to ask one of the staff who either knew off the top of their head or would do a lookup on a beat up old CRT terminal which listed the publisher.

But the selection was incredible. It might have been the biggest bookstore in New England outside of the Harvard Coop. The only comparable sprawling indie bookstores I've see are Powell's in Portland Oregon and Strand in NYC.

Like 90% of bookstores in America, chain or indie or special like this one, Amazon killed it off.

Photos here:

https://www.shelf-awareness.com/issue.html?issue=1611#m14202

https://mleddy.blogspot.com/2010/08/new-england-mobile-book-...

https://thephoenix.com/boston/arts/130690-under-new-ownershi...

ETA: Just found out via the last link that it was 35k square feet, and was located in a former tennis racket factory.

Re: filing system

Its strange system of organizing books by publisher was designed to serve founder (and Jon's father) Louis Strymish's original clientele of librarians and bookstore owners, there to stock their own shelves.

show comments
zippyman55

Libraries used to be so amazing to me as a kid, but the quality of books I observe in them now a days seems so much weaker than what I remember from my youth. I'm bit sure if it is because I have gotten older and wiser, or if the material has just dumbed down. I've donated stacks of library quality material but honestly the libraries find it easier to just sell it at their monthly book sale.

show comments
mrweasel

The internet always seemed completely enthralled by the by the Dewey Decimal System, but it always seemed like a pretty poor way of locating books at the library. Technically my library uses DK5, but same idea. In many cases it's overly specific and in others not specific enough. If you're just looking for something random to read, it's certainly not helping. Bookstores and second hand stores are in many ways much better at exposing you to random literature.

show comments
bsoles

I am rather stuck at

> After passing a $195 million bond measure in 2020...

smartmic

Is there any specification/schematics of the "Wayfinder" system they have introduced?

show comments
vondur

Do they teach the Dewey Decimal system in schools in the US now? I remember being taught it as far back as elementary school. I can see why, it's like organizing files on your computer, it can be a challenge to figure out where to categorize them.

show comments
sinuhe69

I really can not understand why finding a book in a library is still considered a problem when computers are available. When a visitor browse a section, they will find similar books. If they search for a specific book or subject, a computer is the best way to go. Dewey or not is not a problem anymore.

show comments
lavendermon

This is one of those changes that I would never think to be a problem until after it has been implemented. Kudos to the librarians who made it happen, I am hopeful my local library picks up on the idea soon.

erelong

Article sounds confusing, it sounds like they both switched a classification system and way to present the books partially out of some political gripes with Dewey's classifications?

Why not use Library of Congress classification system or are there any others that exist? Why reinvent the wheel?

If there are genuine problems with DDS, why not fork it or just create a version update rather than overhaul for a totally different system?

I guess my issue is the classifications all seem arbitrary at some level, so creating a new system just introduces new arbitrary orderings to memorize.

(Alternatively if these are all "proprietary" systems as some comments suggest, could we create an "open" classificstion system or popularize that kind of system?)

show comments
floren

> Wayfinder eliminates the Dewey reliance on mere numbers, and instead organizes into broad categories and subcategories. A book on growing tomatoes, for example, would be in the Arts and Crafts category, in the gardening subcategory. In the Dewey Decimal System, a book on gardening could potentially be in any of the four places in the system that contained gardening content. With Wayfinder, it’s all in the same place.

This section seems like a misunderstanding of how taxonomies work. Does a book about the architecture in SF's Castro neighborhood belong in History or LGBT or Architecture?

show comments
anArbitraryOne

I guess if one can look up what specific shelf something is on, this is fine, but hopefully it's not hard to find an arbitrary book. But optimizing for browsing does sound like a great idea

hatthew

This is a very subjective take, but the photos make it look like the space is too open and the shelves too small. My favorite part of libraries is the feeling of delving deep into back corners, surrounded by tall stacks of books, with nobody else in sight. Claustrophilia?

kwertyoowiyop

This looks like a great idea for browsing. My local library has all fiction shelved together alphabetically (even in their display of new books) which means you can’t browse in a genre. But on the plus side, they now have genre-specific “staff picks” areas so you can easily grab a popular choice that you’ll probably like.

show comments
johnea

We still have some great book stores here in San Diego.

Like Verbatim Books, where staff can instantly determine if a book is in stock, and go straight to the exact location where it is shelved.

Or, DG Wills, which has an incredible collection, and where the staff will show you to a general section of a room, and say "If we have it, it should be somewhere around here" 8-/

Two rows of books on each shelf (one behind the other!), and you'll be on your knees, with your face next to the floor, trying to go through those books on the bottom shelves.

Bookstore organization varies widely. Dewey Decimal and Library of Congress filing systems were developed to overcome the ambiguity.

Unless they're trying to recover that $195M bond by selling $8 lattes to wandering readers, I don't think abandoning Dewey decimal is a good idea.

I wish someone would index and organize the books at DG Wills, they have some truly great books in the collection, if you can find them...

Animats

There used to be a video rental store in San Francisco which organized videos by cover art. "Guy with gun". "Girl with gun". "Helicopter shooting". "Man kissing woman" It took only about 20 categories to cover Hollywood's output.

phendrenad2

Dewey Decimal hails from an age before computers and barcodes. Nowadays, there's no reason to use numbers, when we could use a usenet-like classification system instead.

sl0wbrainRot

Is this permanent or a short term bump due to a bit of viral attenuation?

New Shiny Thing! messaging drawing a crowd that will eventually realize it's still books. Just a new sorting model.

fastaguy88

The Dewey Decimal System -- haven't seen that since I graduated from high school. Colleges and Universities almost universally use Library of Congress.

bitwize

This is the kind of thing I expect LLMs to be really, uniquely good at: taking a book's content and distilling it into a vector in a multidimensional "topic space". A book about, say, Neil Armstrong could point strongly in the "biography" and "space exploration" directions in topic space, and a querent would be able to search on these topics and pull it up. Books might be organized physically according to their strongest few vector topic components; directions as to where the book might be found in the library could be provided by the querying system.

insane_dreamer

> the libraries’ proprietary Wayfinder system

there is no reason this should be proprietary; that's a step backwards

propter_hoc

This is really lovely. Now I want to visit the Bend OR library!

show comments
rbobby

Quality over quantity?

readthenotes1

I worked in college libraries and they were all Library of Congress Classification scheme because Dewey was so bad for large collections.

Kinda surprised Dewey is still around

tokai

They changed to another kind of classification. The ddc vs bookstore-like is bogus. If you get the funds to reclassify your collection in-house specifically for your users, it better be an upgrade.

show comments
nekusar

Good on them. Dewey Decimal is a hot pile of garbage. Of course initially, it looks good.

     1. Women's work is separate from jobs.
     2. African American culture is separate from American culture.
     3. LGBTQ was initially under "Abnormal psychology" in 1932, then later "Social problems" in 1989, and now "306.7 Sexual orientation, transgenderism, intersexuality" right next to child exploitation and BDSM.
     4. Looking up black poets? Its under 326 Colonization, not american poetry. 
     5. “Working animals,” such as cows, sheep, and horses, are in an entirely separate category from animals including lions and tigers.
     6. Diseases are separate from their cures. 
     7. Boats are found hundreds of decimals away from the sinking of the Titanic.
We can do better. And that doing better is dumping the racist and sexist Dewey Decimal system once and for all.
show comments