The best thing I did wrt Amazon is kill off my Prime account. It eliminates hundreds of even thousands of dollars of wasteful impulse purchases every year.
Most online retailers (Amazon included) still give free shipping above a certain threshold ($35 per order or whatever) so for things I need, I wait until I reach that threshold to place the order, and often purchase at other retailers or directly from the brand.
Also, everyone does "Black Friday" sales nowadays, in many cases matching the same window as Amazon.
show comments
akudha
I've mentally tuned out of words like sale, discount, deal etc when I see them while shopping. It seems most things are on sale most of the time - how is that even possible? As much as I think Apple is arrogant, at least they don't do this crappy "sale" thing. Right now there is a whole page of "deals" on Microsoft https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/store/b/sale
Walk into any store (JC Penny etc) half the items are on sale. Even groceries - go to Safeway, there is a newspaper style coupons - multiple pages. This whole thing is just bizarre and tiring.
show comments
yathern
I recently noticed the same thing in a more specific Niche - 11.11 sales for Mini PCs on AliExpress.
Not just jacking up prices and having fake sale prices (they do that year round) - but a specific pattern to throw off naive URL or SKU based price trackers:
They delist old models, and add them back in, sometimes with different model names, but the same specs. The week before the big sale, there were hundreds of delistings, and the average price rose nearly $80 - so that the $50 off becomes an increase.
I've been tracking Mini PC prices on Amazon for months now and am excited to see if the same pattern repeats for Black Friday. (There's other weird patterns on Amazon, such as listing the same PC 10 times with different prices, all from the same seller, I guess to profit from consumers who don't research much?)
show comments
everdrive
The bigger question is why consumers still think that "sales" mean anything whatsoever. The rug has been pulled so, so many times. It's not even as if the prices are particularly the problem. Items on Amazon tend to be fairly cheap. Paying $10 more than the historic low for a chainsaw on Amazon doesn't really matter to me. The much bigger problems with Amazon have already been discussed ad nauseam: the meaninglessness of review scores, the shared inventory, the counterfeits, etc.
show comments
getfacl
I've been an Amazon customer since they only sold books. However, I have cut way back on my shopping with them.
One of my resolutions this year is to always search for independent sellers (online or brick and mortar) to compare before buying products on Amazon. In nearly all cases I have found a webshop with a better selection and a lower price, even after paying shipping.
show comments
tehlike
I operate https://pricetracker.wtf and m if you are not using camelcamelcamel.com for Amazon, you are leaving money on the table. For folks with plenty of income, it's probably a rounding error, but in general, the prices you can get by waiting a few weeks etc can be 30-40%>
Also most things you can find on AliExpress for cheaper. Don't do edibles, beauty products etc though. I limit my purchases to tools and electronics
show comments
cwoolfe
Isn't that the just the retail game? I don't think this is unique to Amazon. The method I use to search for deals is by filtering for Prime only products (gives a basic quality check) and then filter by price -> lowest first.
show comments
ArchimedesFrsby
Having keepa browser extension and/or using camelcamelcamel website helps a lot with keeping track of pricing trends, in my experience at least.
show comments
nrightnour
This reminds me of DineLA, twice a year when restaurants offer great deals to get people in.
Now it's just used as a free advertising board. 50% of restaurants on there have fake deals, and 5-10% force a prix fixe menu that costs you more than you would have spent normally.
Any affordable distribution/marketing platform will get abused eventually.
nilsherzig
There should be a regulation / law forcing companies to use the "lowest price in the last 30 days" or something like that instead of whatever they are currently using to calculate the sales discount
show comments
newAccount2025
They are really struggling with Earn Trust these days. Their reviews are fake, their brands are random letters, their product search pages push their own stuff, you basically can’t trust it at all. At least the shipping is still fast.
show comments
gwbas1c
There's a lot of deception around the word "sale."
About a decade ago, the state I live in used to have a "sales tax holiday" where, for one weekend, they would waive sales tax.
What all the retailers did was stop having sales for that weekend. Everyone still came, even though the normal sales usually took much more off than the tax savings.
999900000999
In defense of Amazon; I just returned some audio gear to a local music store and the experience was horrible.
A 10% restocking fee, plus a bunch of stupid questions. It should be illegal to charge a restock fee unless you disclose that to me when I buy it.
I’ve never been charged a restock fee with Amazon. In fact I recall assembling a table wrong, and simply telling Amazon.
They refunded the whole cost as store credit.
Buying online has way less friction than going to a store and arguing for 15 minutes about what I really need and turning down financing options.
RIP retail, not sure if I miss you or not.
inanutshellus
To counter this... the business I used to work for absolutely took Black Friday deals seriously. Working there made me less cynical about those deals, because it really was their best effort at amazing deals.
The hope (and result) was that you'd find an amazing "deal" that enticed you to buy at all and once you had that in your cart you'd stick around and see what else we had to offer.
So... keep pervasive cynicism at bay as best you can, folks. :)
assimpleaspossi
If you read the statement differently, I read:
"2 out of every 3 shoppers got savings"
and
"9 out of every 10 offers were cheaper"
which makes me wonder what the article is screaming about. It certainly doesn't sound bad at all.
show comments
dhbradshaw
Years ago, I was astonished to see a sign offering 10 tacos for $5. Clearly a bargain. Got the tacos and split them with my wife.
I later learned that $0.50 was the standard price for a single taco.
show comments
ejb999
This is not new - I used to work in a small pharmacy chain when in HS (now defunct, but similar to CVS) - we often raised prices for 'sales' and advertised things as being 'on sale'...people would flock in and buy things for 20-25% more than they were in the weeks and months before the sale...and this was 45 years ago.
acomjean
I remember Circut City’s “going out of bussiness sale”. The big yellow signs offering big savings. I needed something obscure so I waited till the end. Much of the stuff was cleared out, but the thing i wanted was there at a huge discount from the “original” price netting me almost no savings at all.
It seems those store liquidations are a giant scam. They seem to work though as the store was picked through.
Except tower records, I got some good metal shelving from them.
It attempts to be a damning report, speculating that many households are waiting for holiday sales to afford necessities due to inflation. However, while they are quick to point out that their own data shows nearly 1/3 of the items researched were the same price leading up to the sale, and that about 1/10 of the items were priced higher, the corollary is that 2/3 of the items were truly "on sale" as described. They also did not differentiate between items sold by Amazon and those priced by third-parties through marketplace.
So customers still have to do their own price research (as always), and trust me I have MANY gripes about Amazon, but this is far from an obvious scam.
rdtsc
I call it a "Macy's" trick since that's where I saw it most often. Mattress for $1000, oh but original price is $3000, what a deal! When in reality nobody bought for the original price, it's there just to create the impression of getting a deal. I guess the trick works well enough on most people that it's worth keeping around. I remember some noise about making the practice illegal or putting some guard rails against but I don's how that's practical.
show comments
1970-01-01
Walk around a tourist trap town and do some window shopping. 20-40% on sale signs everywhere. A tactic as old as time. Simply stated: You need to know the old price to know if it is a good price.
show comments
red_green_yell
We sell over $500k/year on Amazon, which means we're a tiny seller, but for what it's worth this reporting is not remotely consistent with our experience. From our side as a smaller seller amazon closely tracks your previous lowest price over various windows ranging from 30-90 days and forces you to run at least 15%-20% off that lowest depending on the window and the sale. There are multiple rules that intersect and are frankly confusing and complicated. But they do force a real discount and if you're going to buy our products you should absolutely do it during BFCM if you want the lowest price.
This analysis focuses on the top 50 promoted items on BFCM, which means we're talking about massive sellers from massive brands like kitchenaid, bose, ninja, etc. So maybe those huge brands get special treatment around these rules. But for joe shmo small sellers like us, the discount policies are strict and real.
Considering the insanely huge number of SKUs sold on amazon, drawing such broad conclusions from such a tiny data set is irresponsible and clearly for clickbait purposes. Their analysis uses Keepa data, the most famous pricing data aggregator. They could have easily broadened their query to the top 10k or 100k skus with minimal extra work.
I say all this as a small seller who's planning to de prioritize amazon because we just can't make a meaningful profit on the platform. So I have no love for the platform and agree with the criticisms of its buyer experience etc. But this article is so highly misleading it only serves to destroy the credibility of its authors.
aborsy
Amazon is +10X better than shopping from brick and mortar stores (in EU at least, which are terrible). Also, better than many other online stores. It took significant pain from my shopping experience.
apparent
I recently got an email saying an item is now in stock, and when I clicked through the price was insane. I figure they're starting the price super high to see how many they can sell to suckers who have been waiting for months, and then they'll have a "sales" on black friday that will bring things down to a regular price. I'm curious to see if they raise prices back up after BF, or if that just becomes the new "normal price".
giamma
In Italy, and I believe in whole Europe, online shops who advertise discounts are required to display in addition to the current price also the best and the average price of the last 30 days.
So when Amazon (or any other shop) says "20% discount" it's easy to spot that the 20% discount is related to MSRP and that the product is regularly discounted 15%, therefore the actual discount is just 5% more and not a whopping 20% over the regular price.
rs999gti
Be warned about the bias of the source:
The Groundwork Collaborative is a Washington, D.C.–based progressive economic think tank, strategic communications hub, and issue advocacy organization founded in 2018.
You will have to understand that amid the current K-shaped economy and a heavy tilt towards AI investment buildouts, compounding on the fact that borrowing costs are way higher in the last few years (it is slightly lower, but it is expected to hike rates three times consecutively in the upcoming FOMC meetings), there are very little money left for the small businesses, that interest rate and inflation kicks in, so there are also very little budget to make a big discount, i.e. be a loss leader. In black Friday you want to trade a small loss on the goods to gain some chances that customers buy other stuff together to hopefully coup up the loss, if not, then see it as a once-in-a-year goodwill. You just no longer have that goodwill money in a more hardcore economic environment and heck the outlook is even worse.
For big business brands like Costco or Walmart, not so sure. They have stable income and they can issue investment grade corporate bond, so they don't need to use black Friday as a marketing gimmick, they could do this all day every day if they wanted. It's just the cost to acquire customer is different and they have the volume to amortize the cost
show comments
wolvoleo
Yeah I noticed this exactly. I've been looking for some specific things and I've been checking prices etc thinking black Friday would offer me another 5-10% off or so. But no. Big labels with DEAL but the price is crap actually. Really weird.
I don't care so much, I'm not in any hurry with most of them. I'll just bide my time. The black Friday thing is something we don't really have much with here, it was the retailers that tried to promote it, bringing it over from the US. Same with the Chinese singles day and others. But it's not a big thing for us here.
dubeyaayush07
Amazon also has price history which can be used to find whether the product is actually available at a lower price
show comments
dsparkman
Amazon is not the only one that does this. Walmart does it all the time and has done it for years. Their roll-backs are notorious for this. They will sell at one price for a period of time, then jack up the price for a week or so, then put the item on roll-back. They will then lower the price to the original price or slightly higher than it was just a few weeks before. The sale is not a sale.
patrakov
My pet peeve: misleading "customers also buy these items" suggestions.
Latest example: I bought a Calibrite ColorChecker Studio spectrophotometer. Amazon suggested that a photo camera calibration target is a good addition, and offered a Mini ColorChecker Classic Target as an additional item to buy. I did so, without knowing that exactly the same target is included in the box. Now I have two.
abeppu
Are third party price trackers (eg camelcamelcamel) still reliable/trustworthy?
I make a habit of checking this before buying on Amazon and it provides good context, but I wonder if a Amazon is actually always showing them the same prices I see?
I find you have to shop around and not just assume Amazon has a good price since, as this study confirms, they often don’t.
Some things are a good deal but lots of stuff is just 30%+ more than what it would cost at a local store or other online retailers.
Oddly it makes little sense at times why some things are a lot more and others are cheaper. With its logistics network Amazon should be able to offer the best prices, but it’s definitely not consistently the best price. Not even close.
A lot of this is driven by FBA stuff that’s just folks reselling stuff at a markup on Amazon. It’s a double whammy of higher prices and search results full of 90% FBA junk.
contubernio
Unfortunately this is exemplary of the business model the predominates currently in the US - cheat, lie, and obfuscate as muchas you can get away with, because anyway in the unlikely event of regulatory action the cost will be outrun by the profit. It reflects a complete collapse of ethics in the mindset of corporate actors.
prmoustache
I never understood black friday and yearly sales. I buy stuff when I need it.
show comments
legitster
The irony is that Black Friday originally existed to clear out old inventory to make room for holiday inventory. They have been such large sales events in their own right that most retailers (Amazon included) actually clear and bring in new inventory specially for the day.
Amazon also used to stock a lot of off-price or liquidated products back in the early days of Prime - as they've scaled up those days are long gone
show comments
Yhippa
Alternatively 2 in 3 deals offered actual savings and 9 in 10 deals were cheaper? I know there are other options.
testbjjl
The definition of sale changed for me a long time ago. A sale has to align with my need for the item/service and is measured by velocity in price, independent of the offer.
adrithmetiqa
I find one of the big challenges here is the advertising stranglehold that Amazon has on Google shopping links. Where do you look for alternative suppliers of a product without endless scrolling through fake review and comparison sites?
origini
That has been the issue for decade and more. Same with some corporate benefits.
If you want to buy something, use a price search engine and research the market yourself to get a good price.
show comments
ZiiS
Wow that is much better then I would have guessed.
hyperbovine
It feels like ~15 years ago you could genuinely find amazing deals on name brand products, particularly during the 7 (or 10? 12?) days of Christmas lightning deals special that they ran. But it's been years I was anything worth buying during their holiday sales.
atmosx
This has been going on in Greece for years. They lie about the real price and then they add the regular price a if it’s a Friday big deal. E.g. the laptop costs 700€ but you see “30% down, ~1000€~ 700€ Black Friday”. So it means nothing…
camhart
I wanted an orange juicer last Christmas. Looked it up on amazon, on sale for $135 when normally costs like $150 or so. I checked pricing history, outside of the holidays it normally sells for $79.
stronglikedan
I've been tracking prices on a couple of things (not on any specific storefront, but in general), and they have been creeping up lately, presumably in preparation for a BF "sale". It's all so tiring, really.
yipinwong
Always use "CamelCamelCamel".
ChrisMarshallNY
Amazon hasn't been price-competitive for ages. They push higher-priced stuff at every opportunity.
maerF0x0
It should be just as illegal to label a "Deal" (sale, discount et al.) that contains no deal/sale/discount as it would be to label a container of apple juice that contains none.
subhro
Lots of people here are saying they can find independent shops with lower pricing. That is true, lots of times, however what makes Amazon come ahead is shipping and 5% cashback with Amazon credit card.
It sucks. :(
ncruces
Not bad: 2 in 3 are actual discounts, 90% don't leave you worse off.
show comments
lavendermon
My wife and I only keep Prime because A) she's still addicted to 2 day shipping, B) I can still find promo deals to make Prime free or very cheap. This is our compromise because cycling through signup accounts for Prime promo deals makes returns and finding past orders a bit more of a hassle. I just don't feel Prime is worth anything close to the full price they charge, that line was crossed about 5 to 7 years ago.
Whether or not a slashed price is actually a lower price has been debated for a long time, I don't find this "research" groundbreaking though it does help confirm some hunches.
I did find it fascinating that this news site hyperlinked itself within the first sentence of its own article.
jghn
There's a resort I like to go to. Every year they have a Black Friday sale. Also, every year, like clockwork, they raise their rates in early November, and then the Black Friday sale just brings things back to the previous price. Go figure.
bix6
Amazon is such a scam. They mark things up and then immediately mark it down so they can show you “10% discount”. Can we get some freaking consumer protection laws my god why is this so contentious.
show comments
dofm
Yes, pretty normal for the prices in the UK to go up 28 days before Black Friday so they can come back down in time for Black Friday to stay within the law. I saw precisely no unusual deals on anything I have been tracking the price on.
(I did find my regular pair of shoes in one of the Prime Deal Days; I basically always buy a pair at that time of year to get new treads for winter, and then wear them flat throughout the year)
WaitWaitWha
Is it still "Amazon", or just an eBay with built-in logistics?
As in, the prices for Amazon products, the article makes sense, but what percentage of the stuff on it is still Amazon? I assume (and, i do not know) that Amazon has some influence on the pricing, but not full control.
sillypuddy
Shocking! We should come up with a phrase to warn people about businesses. Like 'let the buyer beware', but make it sound more historic.
xunil2ycom
Yeah. This has been done by retailers forever.
show comments
yellow_postit
Every year there are articles about retailers raising prices ahead of the holidays to then claim a discount.
If you need it, and can afford to own it, buy it.
If you can’t, don’t let a supposed deal entice your purchase.
DudeOpotomus
The rug shop downtown has been going out of business for 10 years. They have $10,000 rugs marked down to $5000.
anjel
Shopping on Amazon means cutting through so many dark patterns at Amazon these days, the overarching message being, pure contempt for its customers.
show comments
nazgulsenpai
You aught to see Temu. I often laugh at how everything on there, even when it's more expensive than other retailers, is 90% off!
gavin_gee
the good news you can see the fake pricing on the amazon website by just looking at pricing history - they literally put the button at the top. Every sale is a scam.
its just the new version of see price in cart
frabia
Quick tip: install a browser extension like Keepa to see price trends of Amazon products and spot the fake sales.
show comments
Grombobulous
Which actually means 66% of deals do offer savings.
I’m not even sure I would single out Amazon for this practice. Fake markdowns are a tale as old as time. Just look at what happened when JCPenney tried to eliminate sales in favor of straightforward pricing. Customers hated it because they felt like they weren’t getting a deal, they weren’t getting rewarded for scouting out a “find.”
show comments
balls187
Minor credit--they do show you price history up to a year back.
Havoc
Just check price history?
These days I’m buying a lot of tech off eBay and aliexpress anyway. Pricing tends to be better
lordleft
I really feel like this counts as deceptive advertising and should be illegal.
PaulKeeble
camelcamelcamel and Keepa are essential tools for dealing with Amazon, a lot of companies doing dynamic pricing and dodgy sales tactics on it. Amazon is a very poorly regulated seller generally these days.
biker142541
Cool to see some numbers behind what we all know already.
mithr
I mostly keep a wishlist of things I want but don't really need, that I'd get at a deep enough discount. Then during events like BF/CM, I can take a look at the list and see if anything's at a good enough price (it rarely is).
I also find it counterintuitively helpful that so many of Amazon's deals are obviously not actually deals, and that so many of their products are so obviously knockoffs, because when I do find myself scrolling through a "Kitchen sale!" list in the app, it only takes a minute for me to realize this is useless and close the app in disgust.
mring33621
Pretty sure everyone already knew this.
wolfi1
I'm shocked, I tell you, shocked
croisillon
suprised_pikachu.jpg
kittikitti
Big Tech is filled with bots and scammers. The problem is that people don't listen and blindly follow whatever comes out. This isn't news to me, but I don't take everything Big Tech says at face value.
mannyv
camelcamelcamel
aframemodular
Honestly I am surprised then that more than 2/3 of "deals" are actually deals. If you do your research on what you want to get ahead of time and what it should cost, shouldn't this still be a great day for online shopping?
morelandjs
Amazon exposes price history for products. You can see how much something cost under a deal compared to earlier in the year.
andy_b_84
They're still bad at hiding their Ministry of Truth activities, such a shame.
mech998877
This is not a surprise.
jjyycc
That's sad!
timnetworks
The new game is marking things as one-day delivery and then taking the customers money and then not delivering on this promise.
Fuck amazon for doing that. Fuck amazon in general.
Also fuck uber for charing 'waiting fees' for the shitty taxi service, I'm not jumping into a moving car you soul sucking vampires, it needs to be stopped. Fuck uber in general tbh.
show comments
mike_bob
I got a good idea, let's build something to disrupt Amazon! Remember disruption? Where'd that go? Oh right... it was a grift all along making everything worse and more expensive.
inshard
The Amazon price history tool now GA on the mobile app is pretty useful. It goes back a couple of years. Heartbreaking to view for SSD and RAM-linked products. But replaced camelcamelcamel.com for me
reactordev
Amazon is a cancer on the Internet.
If you sell through them, you are not allowed to list your products cheaper than they do otherwise they delist you.
beloch
Amazon was already far up the enshittification curve back in early 2025 when Bezos started openly palling around with the Trump administration. That's when this particular Canadian started their boycott, and I have to thank Amazon for making that decision easy to stick to.
For those who wish to get off of Amazon, all it takes is a little planning or the willingness to go shopping in a physical store. It's no bed of roses for physical stores these days, but the reports of their demise have been greatly exaggerated. Malls are still alive and well in Canada. For things you need to order, don't expect overnight shipping. Plan a little further ahead.
For those who have decided to stick with Amazon a little longer... Do pay attention to the holiday price shenanigans that are about to take place. It's not just in your head when a book you swear you saw last week at $15 is now "on sale" at $40. Christmas is when Amazon becomes truly rapacious.
lowbloodsugar
Welcome to America! Decades ago, when I was new to US, I found a 50% of deal at Macy's for a $100 item. Noticed the price tag was on top of another, so I peeled it off, and the original one underneath said $50.
This isn't illegal. Every company does it. If you want to stop it, change the law. Most passive voters on earth.
j45
The real black friday/cyber monday seems to happen in January/February.
Online retailers are about optimizing their profits at all times and cases, not what customers want.
People can simply not spend and it will get their attention.
Some years, theres no deals.
Inflation is providing enough boosts in profit that they might not care to give out sales to make revenue.
I've made a hard rule to check keepa before Amazon purchases and its probably saved me thousands of dollars over the past couple years. Their practices are absolutely scummy
thraway3837
It’s not just Amazon. It’s every retailer. This is because of timing: US holiday season/Black Friday was historically the best time to buy stuff because of deals. So people expect spectacular deals during these sales events.
However, deals now run throughout the year and prices are usually better on random days so it pays to hunt the deal sites or social media. Physical stores also have better deals and are the only authorized dealer for a lot of brands. Big hardware stores also have 2 hour or same day delivery which is amazing. And you’re guaranteed to not get fakes.
ex1fm3ta
In eelctronics, the items in sale tend to be different from the ones on regular prices. I saw this with powerbank, chargers, usb-c cables ... Visually it`s the same product but specification wise most of the times is quite different.
teeray
Once again, regulation. Perhaps something like “Discount percentages must be calculated from the 52-week median price of the item.”
alienbaby
its kinda one of the oldest tricks in the book. I thought there was legislation to prevent it in bricks and mortar stores, at least here in the UK. I guess it doesnt apply to Amazon huh?
The best thing I did wrt Amazon is kill off my Prime account. It eliminates hundreds of even thousands of dollars of wasteful impulse purchases every year.
Most online retailers (Amazon included) still give free shipping above a certain threshold ($35 per order or whatever) so for things I need, I wait until I reach that threshold to place the order, and often purchase at other retailers or directly from the brand.
Also, everyone does "Black Friday" sales nowadays, in many cases matching the same window as Amazon.
I've mentally tuned out of words like sale, discount, deal etc when I see them while shopping. It seems most things are on sale most of the time - how is that even possible? As much as I think Apple is arrogant, at least they don't do this crappy "sale" thing. Right now there is a whole page of "deals" on Microsoft https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/store/b/sale
Walk into any store (JC Penny etc) half the items are on sale. Even groceries - go to Safeway, there is a newspaper style coupons - multiple pages. This whole thing is just bizarre and tiring.
I recently noticed the same thing in a more specific Niche - 11.11 sales for Mini PCs on AliExpress.
Not just jacking up prices and having fake sale prices (they do that year round) - but a specific pattern to throw off naive URL or SKU based price trackers:
They delist old models, and add them back in, sometimes with different model names, but the same specs. The week before the big sale, there were hundreds of delistings, and the average price rose nearly $80 - so that the $50 off becomes an increase.
https://minipcs.zip/aliexpress-11-11-pricing-tricks/
I've been tracking Mini PC prices on Amazon for months now and am excited to see if the same pattern repeats for Black Friday. (There's other weird patterns on Amazon, such as listing the same PC 10 times with different prices, all from the same seller, I guess to profit from consumers who don't research much?)
The bigger question is why consumers still think that "sales" mean anything whatsoever. The rug has been pulled so, so many times. It's not even as if the prices are particularly the problem. Items on Amazon tend to be fairly cheap. Paying $10 more than the historic low for a chainsaw on Amazon doesn't really matter to me. The much bigger problems with Amazon have already been discussed ad nauseam: the meaninglessness of review scores, the shared inventory, the counterfeits, etc.
I've been an Amazon customer since they only sold books. However, I have cut way back on my shopping with them.
One of my resolutions this year is to always search for independent sellers (online or brick and mortar) to compare before buying products on Amazon. In nearly all cases I have found a webshop with a better selection and a lower price, even after paying shipping.
I operate https://pricetracker.wtf and m if you are not using camelcamelcamel.com for Amazon, you are leaving money on the table. For folks with plenty of income, it's probably a rounding error, but in general, the prices you can get by waiting a few weeks etc can be 30-40%>
Also most things you can find on AliExpress for cheaper. Don't do edibles, beauty products etc though. I limit my purchases to tools and electronics
Isn't that the just the retail game? I don't think this is unique to Amazon. The method I use to search for deals is by filtering for Prime only products (gives a basic quality check) and then filter by price -> lowest first.
Having keepa browser extension and/or using camelcamelcamel website helps a lot with keeping track of pricing trends, in my experience at least.
This reminds me of DineLA, twice a year when restaurants offer great deals to get people in.
Now it's just used as a free advertising board. 50% of restaurants on there have fake deals, and 5-10% force a prix fixe menu that costs you more than you would have spent normally.
Any affordable distribution/marketing platform will get abused eventually.
There should be a regulation / law forcing companies to use the "lowest price in the last 30 days" or something like that instead of whatever they are currently using to calculate the sales discount
They are really struggling with Earn Trust these days. Their reviews are fake, their brands are random letters, their product search pages push their own stuff, you basically can’t trust it at all. At least the shipping is still fast.
There's a lot of deception around the word "sale."
About a decade ago, the state I live in used to have a "sales tax holiday" where, for one weekend, they would waive sales tax.
What all the retailers did was stop having sales for that weekend. Everyone still came, even though the normal sales usually took much more off than the tax savings.
In defense of Amazon; I just returned some audio gear to a local music store and the experience was horrible.
A 10% restocking fee, plus a bunch of stupid questions. It should be illegal to charge a restock fee unless you disclose that to me when I buy it.
I’ve never been charged a restock fee with Amazon. In fact I recall assembling a table wrong, and simply telling Amazon.
They refunded the whole cost as store credit.
Buying online has way less friction than going to a store and arguing for 15 minutes about what I really need and turning down financing options.
RIP retail, not sure if I miss you or not.
To counter this... the business I used to work for absolutely took Black Friday deals seriously. Working there made me less cynical about those deals, because it really was their best effort at amazing deals.
The hope (and result) was that you'd find an amazing "deal" that enticed you to buy at all and once you had that in your cart you'd stick around and see what else we had to offer.
So... keep pervasive cynicism at bay as best you can, folks. :)
If you read the statement differently, I read:
"2 out of every 3 shoppers got savings"
and
"9 out of every 10 offers were cheaper"
which makes me wonder what the article is screaming about. It certainly doesn't sound bad at all.
Years ago, I was astonished to see a sign offering 10 tacos for $5. Clearly a bargain. Got the tacos and split them with my wife.
I later learned that $0.50 was the standard price for a single taco.
This is not new - I used to work in a small pharmacy chain when in HS (now defunct, but similar to CVS) - we often raised prices for 'sales' and advertised things as being 'on sale'...people would flock in and buy things for 20-25% more than they were in the weeks and months before the sale...and this was 45 years ago.
I remember Circut City’s “going out of bussiness sale”. The big yellow signs offering big savings. I needed something obscure so I waited till the end. Much of the stuff was cleared out, but the thing i wanted was there at a huge discount from the “original” price netting me almost no savings at all.
It seems those store liquidations are a giant scam. They seem to work though as the store was picked through.
Except tower records, I got some good metal shelving from them.
The HN link is a press release about the report, the actual report is here: https://groundworkcollaborative.org/work/amazon/
It attempts to be a damning report, speculating that many households are waiting for holiday sales to afford necessities due to inflation. However, while they are quick to point out that their own data shows nearly 1/3 of the items researched were the same price leading up to the sale, and that about 1/10 of the items were priced higher, the corollary is that 2/3 of the items were truly "on sale" as described. They also did not differentiate between items sold by Amazon and those priced by third-parties through marketplace.
So customers still have to do their own price research (as always), and trust me I have MANY gripes about Amazon, but this is far from an obvious scam.
I call it a "Macy's" trick since that's where I saw it most often. Mattress for $1000, oh but original price is $3000, what a deal! When in reality nobody bought for the original price, it's there just to create the impression of getting a deal. I guess the trick works well enough on most people that it's worth keeping around. I remember some noise about making the practice illegal or putting some guard rails against but I don's how that's practical.
Walk around a tourist trap town and do some window shopping. 20-40% on sale signs everywhere. A tactic as old as time. Simply stated: You need to know the old price to know if it is a good price.
We sell over $500k/year on Amazon, which means we're a tiny seller, but for what it's worth this reporting is not remotely consistent with our experience. From our side as a smaller seller amazon closely tracks your previous lowest price over various windows ranging from 30-90 days and forces you to run at least 15%-20% off that lowest depending on the window and the sale. There are multiple rules that intersect and are frankly confusing and complicated. But they do force a real discount and if you're going to buy our products you should absolutely do it during BFCM if you want the lowest price.
This analysis focuses on the top 50 promoted items on BFCM, which means we're talking about massive sellers from massive brands like kitchenaid, bose, ninja, etc. So maybe those huge brands get special treatment around these rules. But for joe shmo small sellers like us, the discount policies are strict and real.
Considering the insanely huge number of SKUs sold on amazon, drawing such broad conclusions from such a tiny data set is irresponsible and clearly for clickbait purposes. Their analysis uses Keepa data, the most famous pricing data aggregator. They could have easily broadened their query to the top 10k or 100k skus with minimal extra work.
I say all this as a small seller who's planning to de prioritize amazon because we just can't make a meaningful profit on the platform. So I have no love for the platform and agree with the criticisms of its buyer experience etc. But this article is so highly misleading it only serves to destroy the credibility of its authors.
Amazon is +10X better than shopping from brick and mortar stores (in EU at least, which are terrible). Also, better than many other online stores. It took significant pain from my shopping experience.
I recently got an email saying an item is now in stock, and when I clicked through the price was insane. I figure they're starting the price super high to see how many they can sell to suckers who have been waiting for months, and then they'll have a "sales" on black friday that will bring things down to a regular price. I'm curious to see if they raise prices back up after BF, or if that just becomes the new "normal price".
In Italy, and I believe in whole Europe, online shops who advertise discounts are required to display in addition to the current price also the best and the average price of the last 30 days.
So when Amazon (or any other shop) says "20% discount" it's easy to spot that the 20% discount is related to MSRP and that the product is regularly discounted 15%, therefore the actual discount is just 5% more and not a whopping 20% over the regular price.
Be warned about the bias of the source:
The Groundwork Collaborative is a Washington, D.C.–based progressive economic think tank, strategic communications hub, and issue advocacy organization founded in 2018.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Groundwork_Collaborative
You will have to understand that amid the current K-shaped economy and a heavy tilt towards AI investment buildouts, compounding on the fact that borrowing costs are way higher in the last few years (it is slightly lower, but it is expected to hike rates three times consecutively in the upcoming FOMC meetings), there are very little money left for the small businesses, that interest rate and inflation kicks in, so there are also very little budget to make a big discount, i.e. be a loss leader. In black Friday you want to trade a small loss on the goods to gain some chances that customers buy other stuff together to hopefully coup up the loss, if not, then see it as a once-in-a-year goodwill. You just no longer have that goodwill money in a more hardcore economic environment and heck the outlook is even worse.
For big business brands like Costco or Walmart, not so sure. They have stable income and they can issue investment grade corporate bond, so they don't need to use black Friday as a marketing gimmick, they could do this all day every day if they wanted. It's just the cost to acquire customer is different and they have the volume to amortize the cost
Yeah I noticed this exactly. I've been looking for some specific things and I've been checking prices etc thinking black Friday would offer me another 5-10% off or so. But no. Big labels with DEAL but the price is crap actually. Really weird.
I don't care so much, I'm not in any hurry with most of them. I'll just bide my time. The black Friday thing is something we don't really have much with here, it was the retailers that tried to promote it, bringing it over from the US. Same with the Chinese singles day and others. But it's not a big thing for us here.
Amazon also has price history which can be used to find whether the product is actually available at a lower price
Amazon is not the only one that does this. Walmart does it all the time and has done it for years. Their roll-backs are notorious for this. They will sell at one price for a period of time, then jack up the price for a week or so, then put the item on roll-back. They will then lower the price to the original price or slightly higher than it was just a few weeks before. The sale is not a sale.
My pet peeve: misleading "customers also buy these items" suggestions.
Latest example: I bought a Calibrite ColorChecker Studio spectrophotometer. Amazon suggested that a photo camera calibration target is a good addition, and offered a Mini ColorChecker Classic Target as an additional item to buy. I did so, without knowing that exactly the same target is included in the box. Now I have two.
Are third party price trackers (eg camelcamelcamel) still reliable/trustworthy? I make a habit of checking this before buying on Amazon and it provides good context, but I wonder if a Amazon is actually always showing them the same prices I see?
Isnt this illegal? https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-B...
I find you have to shop around and not just assume Amazon has a good price since, as this study confirms, they often don’t.
Some things are a good deal but lots of stuff is just 30%+ more than what it would cost at a local store or other online retailers.
Oddly it makes little sense at times why some things are a lot more and others are cheaper. With its logistics network Amazon should be able to offer the best prices, but it’s definitely not consistently the best price. Not even close.
A lot of this is driven by FBA stuff that’s just folks reselling stuff at a markup on Amazon. It’s a double whammy of higher prices and search results full of 90% FBA junk.
Unfortunately this is exemplary of the business model the predominates currently in the US - cheat, lie, and obfuscate as muchas you can get away with, because anyway in the unlikely event of regulatory action the cost will be outrun by the profit. It reflects a complete collapse of ethics in the mindset of corporate actors.
I never understood black friday and yearly sales. I buy stuff when I need it.
The irony is that Black Friday originally existed to clear out old inventory to make room for holiday inventory. They have been such large sales events in their own right that most retailers (Amazon included) actually clear and bring in new inventory specially for the day.
Amazon also used to stock a lot of off-price or liquidated products back in the early days of Prime - as they've scaled up those days are long gone
Alternatively 2 in 3 deals offered actual savings and 9 in 10 deals were cheaper? I know there are other options.
The definition of sale changed for me a long time ago. A sale has to align with my need for the item/service and is measured by velocity in price, independent of the offer.
I find one of the big challenges here is the advertising stranglehold that Amazon has on Google shopping links. Where do you look for alternative suppliers of a product without endless scrolling through fake review and comparison sites?
That has been the issue for decade and more. Same with some corporate benefits.
If you want to buy something, use a price search engine and research the market yourself to get a good price.
Wow that is much better then I would have guessed.
It feels like ~15 years ago you could genuinely find amazing deals on name brand products, particularly during the 7 (or 10? 12?) days of Christmas lightning deals special that they ran. But it's been years I was anything worth buying during their holiday sales.
This has been going on in Greece for years. They lie about the real price and then they add the regular price a if it’s a Friday big deal. E.g. the laptop costs 700€ but you see “30% down, ~1000€~ 700€ Black Friday”. So it means nothing…
I wanted an orange juicer last Christmas. Looked it up on amazon, on sale for $135 when normally costs like $150 or so. I checked pricing history, outside of the holidays it normally sells for $79.
I've been tracking prices on a couple of things (not on any specific storefront, but in general), and they have been creeping up lately, presumably in preparation for a BF "sale". It's all so tiring, really.
Always use "CamelCamelCamel".
Amazon hasn't been price-competitive for ages. They push higher-priced stuff at every opportunity.
It should be just as illegal to label a "Deal" (sale, discount et al.) that contains no deal/sale/discount as it would be to label a container of apple juice that contains none.
Lots of people here are saying they can find independent shops with lower pricing. That is true, lots of times, however what makes Amazon come ahead is shipping and 5% cashback with Amazon credit card.
It sucks. :(
Not bad: 2 in 3 are actual discounts, 90% don't leave you worse off.
My wife and I only keep Prime because A) she's still addicted to 2 day shipping, B) I can still find promo deals to make Prime free or very cheap. This is our compromise because cycling through signup accounts for Prime promo deals makes returns and finding past orders a bit more of a hassle. I just don't feel Prime is worth anything close to the full price they charge, that line was crossed about 5 to 7 years ago.
Whether or not a slashed price is actually a lower price has been debated for a long time, I don't find this "research" groundbreaking though it does help confirm some hunches.
I did find it fascinating that this news site hyperlinked itself within the first sentence of its own article.
There's a resort I like to go to. Every year they have a Black Friday sale. Also, every year, like clockwork, they raise their rates in early November, and then the Black Friday sale just brings things back to the previous price. Go figure.
Amazon is such a scam. They mark things up and then immediately mark it down so they can show you “10% discount”. Can we get some freaking consumer protection laws my god why is this so contentious.
Yes, pretty normal for the prices in the UK to go up 28 days before Black Friday so they can come back down in time for Black Friday to stay within the law. I saw precisely no unusual deals on anything I have been tracking the price on.
(I did find my regular pair of shoes in one of the Prime Deal Days; I basically always buy a pair at that time of year to get new treads for winter, and then wear them flat throughout the year)
Is it still "Amazon", or just an eBay with built-in logistics?
As in, the prices for Amazon products, the article makes sense, but what percentage of the stuff on it is still Amazon? I assume (and, i do not know) that Amazon has some influence on the pricing, but not full control.
Shocking! We should come up with a phrase to warn people about businesses. Like 'let the buyer beware', but make it sound more historic.
Yeah. This has been done by retailers forever.
Every year there are articles about retailers raising prices ahead of the holidays to then claim a discount.
If you need it, and can afford to own it, buy it.
If you can’t, don’t let a supposed deal entice your purchase.
The rug shop downtown has been going out of business for 10 years. They have $10,000 rugs marked down to $5000.
Shopping on Amazon means cutting through so many dark patterns at Amazon these days, the overarching message being, pure contempt for its customers.
You aught to see Temu. I often laugh at how everything on there, even when it's more expensive than other retailers, is 90% off!
the good news you can see the fake pricing on the amazon website by just looking at pricing history - they literally put the button at the top. Every sale is a scam.
its just the new version of see price in cart
Quick tip: install a browser extension like Keepa to see price trends of Amazon products and spot the fake sales.
Which actually means 66% of deals do offer savings.
I’m not even sure I would single out Amazon for this practice. Fake markdowns are a tale as old as time. Just look at what happened when JCPenney tried to eliminate sales in favor of straightforward pricing. Customers hated it because they felt like they weren’t getting a deal, they weren’t getting rewarded for scouting out a “find.”
Minor credit--they do show you price history up to a year back.
Just check price history?
These days I’m buying a lot of tech off eBay and aliexpress anyway. Pricing tends to be better
I really feel like this counts as deceptive advertising and should be illegal.
camelcamelcamel and Keepa are essential tools for dealing with Amazon, a lot of companies doing dynamic pricing and dodgy sales tactics on it. Amazon is a very poorly regulated seller generally these days.
Cool to see some numbers behind what we all know already.
I mostly keep a wishlist of things I want but don't really need, that I'd get at a deep enough discount. Then during events like BF/CM, I can take a look at the list and see if anything's at a good enough price (it rarely is).
I also find it counterintuitively helpful that so many of Amazon's deals are obviously not actually deals, and that so many of their products are so obviously knockoffs, because when I do find myself scrolling through a "Kitchen sale!" list in the app, it only takes a minute for me to realize this is useless and close the app in disgust.
Pretty sure everyone already knew this.
I'm shocked, I tell you, shocked
suprised_pikachu.jpg
Big Tech is filled with bots and scammers. The problem is that people don't listen and blindly follow whatever comes out. This isn't news to me, but I don't take everything Big Tech says at face value.
camelcamelcamel
Honestly I am surprised then that more than 2/3 of "deals" are actually deals. If you do your research on what you want to get ahead of time and what it should cost, shouldn't this still be a great day for online shopping?
Amazon exposes price history for products. You can see how much something cost under a deal compared to earlier in the year.
They're still bad at hiding their Ministry of Truth activities, such a shame.
This is not a surprise.
That's sad!
The new game is marking things as one-day delivery and then taking the customers money and then not delivering on this promise.
Fuck amazon for doing that. Fuck amazon in general.
Also fuck uber for charing 'waiting fees' for the shitty taxi service, I'm not jumping into a moving car you soul sucking vampires, it needs to be stopped. Fuck uber in general tbh.
I got a good idea, let's build something to disrupt Amazon! Remember disruption? Where'd that go? Oh right... it was a grift all along making everything worse and more expensive.
The Amazon price history tool now GA on the mobile app is pretty useful. It goes back a couple of years. Heartbreaking to view for SSD and RAM-linked products. But replaced camelcamelcamel.com for me
Amazon is a cancer on the Internet.
If you sell through them, you are not allowed to list your products cheaper than they do otherwise they delist you.
Amazon was already far up the enshittification curve back in early 2025 when Bezos started openly palling around with the Trump administration. That's when this particular Canadian started their boycott, and I have to thank Amazon for making that decision easy to stick to.
For those who wish to get off of Amazon, all it takes is a little planning or the willingness to go shopping in a physical store. It's no bed of roses for physical stores these days, but the reports of their demise have been greatly exaggerated. Malls are still alive and well in Canada. For things you need to order, don't expect overnight shipping. Plan a little further ahead.
For those who have decided to stick with Amazon a little longer... Do pay attention to the holiday price shenanigans that are about to take place. It's not just in your head when a book you swear you saw last week at $15 is now "on sale" at $40. Christmas is when Amazon becomes truly rapacious.
Welcome to America! Decades ago, when I was new to US, I found a 50% of deal at Macy's for a $100 item. Noticed the price tag was on top of another, so I peeled it off, and the original one underneath said $50.
This isn't illegal. Every company does it. If you want to stop it, change the law. Most passive voters on earth.
The real black friday/cyber monday seems to happen in January/February.
Online retailers are about optimizing their profits at all times and cases, not what customers want.
People can simply not spend and it will get their attention.
Some years, theres no deals.
Inflation is providing enough boosts in profit that they might not care to give out sales to make revenue.
Retail is about creating profit, not the product.
Hasn't Wirecutter literally been reporting this for the best part of a decade now? Here's an article from over 5 years ago: https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/blog/why-most-deals-arent...
I've made a hard rule to check keepa before Amazon purchases and its probably saved me thousands of dollars over the past couple years. Their practices are absolutely scummy
It’s not just Amazon. It’s every retailer. This is because of timing: US holiday season/Black Friday was historically the best time to buy stuff because of deals. So people expect spectacular deals during these sales events.
However, deals now run throughout the year and prices are usually better on random days so it pays to hunt the deal sites or social media. Physical stores also have better deals and are the only authorized dealer for a lot of brands. Big hardware stores also have 2 hour or same day delivery which is amazing. And you’re guaranteed to not get fakes.
In eelctronics, the items in sale tend to be different from the ones on regular prices. I saw this with powerbank, chargers, usb-c cables ... Visually it`s the same product but specification wise most of the times is quite different.
Once again, regulation. Perhaps something like “Discount percentages must be calculated from the 52-week median price of the item.”
its kinda one of the oldest tricks in the book. I thought there was legislation to prevent it in bricks and mortar stores, at least here in the UK. I guess it doesnt apply to Amazon huh?
now do grocery stores