Using keyup makes no sense and is inconsistent with user expectations. For triggering actions (which includes normal typing), you only ever use keydown. (Well, there’s one exception for reasons unclear to me: activating a button by pressing Space. That triggers on keyup like how clicks are on release, while Enter triggers on keydown.) Keyup is limited to things where you’re constantly reacting to the state of a key, as is common in games.
This affects the functionality, too. It is in fact introducing latency by using keyup instead of keydown. Feels bad.
skybrian
This autocomplete suggests domains that don't exist. You can just type garbage and it will suggest something, but then if you go there, there are no records.
It seems like one purpose of an autocomplete box is help you avoid typos, so that makes it less useful.
kevmo314
If you’d like to reduce the network latency further you can store each trie node as a file, naming it conveniently the prefix path to that node. Then dump the few hundred million files onto R2.
Now the traversal can be done completely via CDN lookups!
ViscountPenguin
Unfortunately this approach doesn't feel that great down here in Australia, definitely a function of latency.
I think you could get a lot closer by framing this as an optimization problem, where you use the full alphabet dictionary, but add a residual prediction which aims to cover as much of the remaining domain name tree as possible weighted by popularity. This tree could then be pre-baked and stored with the same system. This would probably get you p99 0ms even in Australia.
camel_gopher
Clever but that’s not how we measure latency.
show comments
pupppet
Autocomplete aside, this is a pretty nifty tool.
pixelpoet
Pretty sure we mean < 1ms rather than actually instantaneous.
show comments
bagels
Looks more like 500ms?
ChannelFence
its pretty clever but what happns when someone pastes a domain or uses IME or voice input? the api being that fast is still impressive.
cortesoft
KeyDown events don’t work great for mobile, though.
Using keyup makes no sense and is inconsistent with user expectations. For triggering actions (which includes normal typing), you only ever use keydown. (Well, there’s one exception for reasons unclear to me: activating a button by pressing Space. That triggers on keyup like how clicks are on release, while Enter triggers on keydown.) Keyup is limited to things where you’re constantly reacting to the state of a key, as is common in games.
This affects the functionality, too. It is in fact introducing latency by using keyup instead of keydown. Feels bad.
This autocomplete suggests domains that don't exist. You can just type garbage and it will suggest something, but then if you go there, there are no records.
It seems like one purpose of an autocomplete box is help you avoid typos, so that makes it less useful.
If you’d like to reduce the network latency further you can store each trie node as a file, naming it conveniently the prefix path to that node. Then dump the few hundred million files onto R2.
Now the traversal can be done completely via CDN lookups!
Unfortunately this approach doesn't feel that great down here in Australia, definitely a function of latency.
I think you could get a lot closer by framing this as an optimization problem, where you use the full alphabet dictionary, but add a residual prediction which aims to cover as much of the remaining domain name tree as possible weighted by popularity. This tree could then be pre-baked and stored with the same system. This would probably get you p99 0ms even in Australia.
Clever but that’s not how we measure latency.
Autocomplete aside, this is a pretty nifty tool.
Pretty sure we mean < 1ms rather than actually instantaneous.
Looks more like 500ms?
its pretty clever but what happns when someone pastes a domain or uses IME or voice input? the api being that fast is still impressive.
KeyDown events don’t work great for mobile, though.