I'm still kind of surprised that people are targeting edge deployment of MoE models. By definition they optimize for computation cost at the expense of memory efficiency. We generally need the opposite on the edge.
I'm hoping to see more work in the other direction with cyclic/looped transformers and other memory dense approaches.
rohansood15
Have you benchmarked against other 3-bit dynamic quants like Unsloth? I am sorry but this framing against a full precision, newer, smaller MoE just seems misleading. Also, Gemma-4-26B-A4B is not the SOTA for edge. Even at launch, that would be the 31B.
show comments
VikRubenfeld
You've likely heard about this - he'd probably like to talk to you and might potentially give you some good PR.
I like the technique described here around distillation to recover from quantization, but I don't understand why we keep performing lossy compression on LLMs then using benchmarks that were nearly saturated before post-training to measure the effects.
You could erase the gains from literally half the compute going into some of these recent models and barely make a dent in MMLU-Pro and GPQA-D.
I'm still kind of surprised that people are targeting edge deployment of MoE models. By definition they optimize for computation cost at the expense of memory efficiency. We generally need the opposite on the edge.
I'm hoping to see more work in the other direction with cyclic/looped transformers and other memory dense approaches.
Have you benchmarked against other 3-bit dynamic quants like Unsloth? I am sorry but this framing against a full precision, newer, smaller MoE just seems misleading. Also, Gemma-4-26B-A4B is not the SOTA for edge. Even at launch, that would be the 31B.
You've likely heard about this - he'd probably like to talk to you and might potentially give you some good PR.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rAzT5lcezPs&t=467s
I like the technique described here around distillation to recover from quantization, but I don't understand why we keep performing lossy compression on LLMs then using benchmarks that were nearly saturated before post-training to measure the effects.
You could erase the gains from literally half the compute going into some of these recent models and barely make a dent in MMLU-Pro and GPQA-D.